scratchpad:search:focus_groups:summary
Table of Contents
Summary of Search Focus Group Discussions
The ideas contained on this page came from the four IRC focus group discussions conducted in March 2016 as well as in follow-up emails on the topic.
What People Like About the Current Search
- Facets for bibliographic data
- Ability for search to handle diacritics properly
- Ability to handle anchored searches (e.g. “^harry potter” to identify indexed fields that begin with “harry potter)
- Autocomplete / autosuggest functionality that predicts search as the user types
- The ability for Evergreen sites to create custom indexes
- The ability to define search formats based on MARC fixed fields
- Strong advanced search filtering – specifically copy location and format filtering
- The ability to search a lot of MARC data in a keyword search - Keyword searching works very well for vast majority of searches due to good coverage of the record
- Ability to search by ISBN in both numeric and keyword search.
- Ability to search by barcode
- Session-less searching, allows linking to search results
- Separate scope and search depth ranging (i.e you can choose to search a particular location and then search at a depth (branch, system, consortium) in the context of that location)
- Call number shelf browse
Ideas for Improvements to Search
- Improved speed
- In general
- When applying Copy location / format filters
- When conducting broad searches.
- Better balance between fuzziness and precision when records are retrieved based on word variations
- Improving search retrieval/relevance through analysis of user behavior, handled in a way that respects user privacy
- Improve relevance for data-rich, higher quality records so that similar records with less MARC data don't consistently rank higher than the longer records.
- True blending of relevance factors, e.g. bib-relevance and popularity providing intelligent bumps that result in better relevance ranking.
- Improve relevance for one-word titles
- Autocomplete / autosuggest improvements
- Improve relevance-ranking for suggested terms
- Work properly with screen readers
- Highlight matching terms with diacritics
- Ability to search public copy notes
- More flexibility in the types of facets that can be defined
- pub date
- formats
- audience
- fiction vs. non-fiction
- language
- Did You Mean? Suggestions
- Improved speed for ingesting records
- Improvements to zero-hit searches
- Drops user into a browse search
- Suggest a meaningful alternative search
- Automatically launch a popular, similar search
- No core limit to # of search results
- When search hits maximum records that can be retrieved, it should inform the user not all results were retrieved and provide tips for narrowing the search.
- Intermediate results screen in keyword searches that first show author / subject headings that matches terms entered in author/subject search, and then brings the user to results for that heading.
- Leverage authority cross-references in keyword search results – related search
- Ability to manually tweak metarecord groupings
- Including prefixes in call number searching
- More browse search options
- Call number (on browse search page)'
- Publisher
- Date
- Journal title
- The ability to pull in external, linked data or canned information to the search results page that is related to the user's search terms. (Example: search for a celebrity on Google, info on the celebrity appears on the right.)
- Search also retrieves public lists (bookbags) on the same topic.
- Intuitive way for users to provide hints for type of material are more relevant (e.g. “for a paper” “for leisure reading” etc.)
- Ability to have a non-keyword search that just sorts by format, location, and date (e.g. "give me the newest DVDs for my library")
- Local synonym list / thesaurus
- Catalog tells users which word variations were used in their search and gives them the choice to search the exact terms only.
- Search augmented with external, curated disambiguation information / related, broader, narrower information.
- Improve metarecord grouping / display so that “group formats and editions” search could be the main result set for most searches.
- Ability to quickly jump from record to other formats/editions of same work
- Using OCLC Work Entities to group metarecords
- Ability for end user to toggle on/off "Search within contents and summary notes?".
- True blending of relevance factors, e.g. bib-relevance and popularity providing intelligent bumps that result in better relevance ranking.
- Single search across library materials, articles, digital repository objects, Overdrive, etc.
- Highlighted search terms
- The ability for the UI show why some records are more relevant than others (relevance scores?
- Easier / more understandable to configure search.
- New sort options for Date Created
- Add ability to sort by shelving location in Shelf Browse
- Search by prefix/suffix
Suggested Improvements that Can Be Done With Configuration
- Weighting for particular fields (title, main author)
- Searching by collections (copy location groups?)
- Sometimes need to use apostrophe to find the correct record (look at normalizers)
- More popular titles floating higher (coming in 2.11)
Factors to be Included in Relevance Ranking
- Currency
- # of copies
- # of circs, holds (or other activity, popularity)
- Specific fields are more important
- Proximity of search terms
- # of times search term appears in record
Top Priorities for Improvement
- Speed
- Better balance between fuzziness / precision
- Leveraging cross-references
- Intermediate search screen for results
- Improved relevance
- Spelling assistance / Did You Mean?
- Better blending of coverage density with other relevance factors (e.g. activity)
- Make it more understandable to see why system is retrieving / ranking as it does (because then it's easier to adjust it.)
Ideas for Non-Search Catalog Improvements
- Improvements for saving and sharing lists
- Easier list management, moving titles between lists
- Usability / language improvements for facets on search results page.
- Integrate GoodReads ratings into search results page
- Carousel for new books
scratchpad/search/focus_groups/summary.txt · Last modified: 2022/02/10 13:34 by 127.0.0.1